Too Fat To Kill - My9 New Jersey

Too Fat To Kill

Posted: Updated:
Hackensack, New Jersey (My9NJ) - Ed Ates made headlines when his defense attorney suggested he was simply too overweight and too weak to murder his daughter’s ex-husband, Paul Duncsak. Ates was convicted of waiting in the basement stairwell of Duncsak’s Ramsey, New Jersey home where he jumped up several stairs, fired 7 shots with a pistol without missing, and then drove over 21 hours to Louisiana within the next 24 hours.

Well, according to his attorney, Walter Lesnevich, that simply wasn’t possible for Ates because of his physical condition.

“Mr Ates was 60, 5’8, 300 pounds, with asthma, grossly obese, terrible shape,” he said.

Ates was convicted based on three pieces of circumstantial evidence as well as a wiretapped phone call. Lesnevich claims that the circumstantial evidence would not have been enough to convict his client on their own. These included the fact that Ates had purchased a lock picking set, and the victim’s home lock was picked. In addition, he purchased information on how to make a silencer, and there was a silencer used in the murder. And lastly, he purchased a book on “how to commit the perfect murder”.

Lesnevich feels the only piece of damning evidence was a wiretapped phone call between Ates and his sister. In the phone call, Ates allegedly asked his sister to corroborate his alibi. Ates was on his cell phone in Florida during the phone call, and his sister was in Louisiana. The prosecutor obtained a warrant from a NJ judge and tapped into the phones from NJ.

The NJ wiretapping law allows you to wiretap anyone, anywhere in the country who is on a cell phone, as long as the person wiretapping the call is in NJ, and as long as you have the appropriate warrant.

“That means they can wiretap anybody talking to anyone anywhere,” Lesnevich said,

Lesnevich believes this practice is unconstitutional and against our 4th amendment rights which protects us from unreasonable search and seizure.

“I think it’s unreasonable to say that when I’m in my home a judge from some other state can control whether I’m wiretapped or not,” Lesnevich argued.

The NJ Supreme Court agreed to hear his appeal based on this. On Tuesday, Lesnevich will present an oral argument that affirms the wiretapped conversation of his client should not have been admissible evidence, and that his client deserves a new trial.

Ates is now serving time for the rest of his life in maximum security Trenton State Prison, but has always maintained his innocence.


Watch Chasing New Jersey weeknights at 10pm on My9 and don’t forget to like us on Facebook!

  • Chasing New JerseyMore>>

  • NJ Doctor Offering Alternative To Obamacare?

    NJ Doctor Offering Alternative To Obamacare?

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 1:24 PM EDT2014-09-02 17:24:21 GMT
    Doctor Alieta Eck is running for U.S. Congress in the 12th district as a Republican. She's recently made headlines due to a free clinic that she created back in 2003 with her husband called the Zarephath Health Center. The clinic is a 501C3 run by volunteers and funded through donations. The average cost per patient that Dr. Eck sees is about $13.Some people are referring to this center as an alternative to Obamacare.
    Doctor Alieta Eck is running for U.S. Congress in the 12th district as a Republican. She's recently made headlines due to a free clinic that she created back in 2003 with her husband called the Zarephath Health Center. The clinic is a 501C3 run by volunteers and funded through donations. The average cost per patient that Dr. Eck sees is about $13.Some people are referring to this center as an alternative to Obamacare.
  • Is The Boston Bomber’s Family In North Bergen A Threat?

    Is The Boston Bomber’s Family In North Bergen A Threat?

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 11:31 AM EDT2014-09-02 15:31:20 GMT
    The widow of the alleged Boston Marathon bomber, Katherine Russell, has been living in North Bergen with the sisters of her former husband, Bella and Ailina Tsarnaev. Neighbors in the area have just recently been made aware of her presence in town, but not all of them are happy about it.
    The widow of the alleged Boston Marathon bomber, Katherine Russell, has been living in North Bergen with the sisters of her former husband, Bella and Aliana Tsarnaev . Neighbors in the area have just recently been made aware of her presence in town, but not all of them are happy about it.
  • NJ Couple Combating The Stray Cat Problem In Union City

    NJ Couple Combating The Stray Cat Problem In Union City

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 11:11 AM EDT2014-09-02 15:11:46 GMT
    Union City has a major stray cat problem. Hundreds of cats are overtaking the city streets and Mercy Garcia and her husband Miguel Fernandez, founders of TLC Rescue, have been doing an unbelievable job of getting the situation under control, but they need help. So far, the couple has been able to round up over 200 felines, but they say there are hundreds more that need help.
    Union City has a major stray cat problem. Hundreds of cats are overtaking the city streets and Mercy Garcia and her husband Miguel Fernandez, founders of TLC Rescue, have been doing an unbelievable job of getting the situation under control, but they need help. So far, the couple has been able to round up over 200 felines, but they say there are hundreds more that need help.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices